To prepare for the production of my own short film I first had to watch some of the other short films out there:
Strangers
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpjHSiQLPmA
The theme of this film is strength through unity.
Two strangers sit opposite each other on a subway train. One is Jewish and the other a Muslim. Neo-Nazis board the train and begin to taunt and intimidate the Muslim character whilst the Jewish character pretends he not to notice and ignores it whilst hiding his Star of David pendant. As the Jewish man is about to leave his cell phone rings, his ring tone is a song universally associated with Judaism - the Neo-Nazis now know his religion. After a tense pause from all concerned both men swap bags and tackle their way through the Neo-Nazis who then chase them along the carriage, the two men manage to escape and end up on opposite platforms whilst the Neo-Nazis are stuck on the train. The two men give a cheer, give each other back the right bag and continue on their separate ways.
This film had no dialogue whatsover apart from when the two main characters cheer at the end. The only other sounds heard were ambient sound in the form of the train along with the announcements and faint incidental music both when the Neo-Nazis first appeared and when the men are being chased by them. This added to the atmosphere of the entire film and amplified the intensity of the moment.
The Neo-Nazis spray painted a Swastika onto the newspaper the Muslim character was reading - Although originally used in Indian religions as an innocent religious symbol its infamous association with the Hitler period and Nazi Germany now means that semiotically the Swastika is seen as a sign of racism, both of its meanings are fitting for this film.
El Diablo Pinata
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jpr24DEDRGI
The theme of this film is revenge and is dealt with in a somewhat satirical manner.
Like many thrillers this film involves the lead protagonist, or 'good guy', following the antagonist who has killed their loved one, the 'bad guy', and eventually the film will reach a climax wherein revenge will be carried out resulting in the death of the original killer, this film is no different - except the 'good guy' is a Piñata.
Lighting plays an important factor in creating mood in this short. In the beginning, from the establishing shot, the colours are bright and mostly white which reflects the calmness and serenity of the character at that moment in time. Later when the antagonist has arrived at a friends house he is shaken, confused and scared as he has seen the protagonist almost everywhere he turns, the lighting has become noticeably darker. Then, in the final scene, when it has been revealed who the 'good guy' and the 'bad guy' really are (Which is the opposite to what the viewer is initially led to believe) and who the antagonist has killed, the protagonist (The Piñata) carries out his revenge. The lighting in this scene is much darker than ever before which reflects the imminent death of the character and the denouement of the narrative.
Sound balances the sombre mood said by the lighting. From the beginning happy upbeat non-diagetic music is heard that fits with the light colours. When the Piñata appears however, sinister non-diagetic music is heard. If this was a conventional thriller short film then this would add suspense and the viewer would feel fear for the boy, but as the so far assumed 'bad guy' is a Piñata it lightens the mood and adds humour. Also, when the credits roll we see a wall of the room where antagonist is being killed and we see blood spatter all over the walls, the happy upbeat music that began in the establishing shot has returned. The juxtaposition of this would usually seem out of place and incredibly disturbing but given the comedic nature of this piece it is rather fitting.
As is the case with many violent scenes in thrillers and horrors we do not actually see the act performed - we are steered into imagining that the act is being performed. The act is that of the antagonist is being killed and we are led to believe / imagine this through how the narrative has developed, the lighting and what we associate images of being gagged and blood with. He may not be being harmed at all, it is left up to our imagination. This method has been used to great effect in films such as
Resovoir Dogs and
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre.
This film was made by A level Film students. Although this was made by film students it was good to watch as I could see what people with or around the same level of knowledge of film making and what can be achieved.
Balance
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=91bNp7HJolE
The main theme of this film is greed.
This theme is displayed through five people standing on a platform with a music box on it. The box and the sounds coming from it are so alien and mysterious to these people that they all want it for themselves and will kill the others to get it. However, the platform is only level when there is the right amount of balance and weight distributed on it otherwise it tilts. When all but one of the people are left on the platform the music box is at the opposite end and therefore impossible to get to without the platform tilting and the box falling.
The colour theme is miserable and morbid, everything is a differing shade of grey with the box being a dark red. All of the people are dressed in exactly the same clothes and would be undistinguishable if it wasn't for the numbers printed on the back of their coats. As a result of this it is almost as if in effect they are killing themselves to get something they cannot have.
There is no dialogue or soundtrack whatsoever in this piece, the only sounds heard are diagetic and ambient - the creaking of the platform / music from the box / the sliding of the box. This enables the viewer to focus on what is happening and more emphasis is laid upon the mysterious box. The juxtaposition of 'happy' and upbeat music emanating from the box and the murderous content creates an eerie and disturbing feel that remains with the viewer until the end.
Special Delivery
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vm1jqkCvQx8
This film deals with the themes of death, crime and infidelity.
Unlike the other films I have analysed,
Special Delivery is an animated cartoon piece. Already this sets it apart significantly from the others as the characters within it are drawn so their movements / appearances are not restricted and do not have to look 100% realistic.
The narrative revolves around the death of a mail man after he slips on the icy steps of a couple's house after the husband didn't clear the steps even though his wife told him to do so. When the husband returns he sees the body of the mail man and quickly hides it as he fears he will be sued by the Union. He then covers his tracks so to speak by posing as the mail man so it looks like he finished his working day and doesn't create suspicion. When he returns home again he realises he is locked out and tries to climb through a window, the police spot and arrest him as they think he is breaking into the house, as the body of the mail man is in there he does not argue. The wife returns, sees the body and thinks the mail man has broken in to try and 'woo' her back after a brief affair they had and fallen asleep, not wanting her husband to find him to takes him home. When she realises he is actually dead she thinks her husband found out about the affair and killed the mail man, fearing death herself she runs away to start a new life.
The non-diagetic music that accompanies the opening titles have an eerie feel to them which when accompanied by a fairly neutral typeface and colour confuse the viewer as they cannot fully de-construct what the narrative is going to involve. However, as the titles fade the music becomes slightly more cheerful which heightens the viewers expectations of a 'happy' film. We are aware of what is happening within the narrative as a voice-over accompanies the images and narrates the story throughout. This is rather effective with regards to short films it would take a much longer time to fully understand and establish what is happening within the world of the narrative and the minds of the characters but with a narrator, especially one that is completely detached from the characters, we receive an un-biased and clearer account of events. We do not hear the dialogue between the characters clearly, rather it is just muffled sounds with the narrator summarising what they are saying.
The Handless Pianist
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAArglZ60C0
This short film is about a man who is a double amputee and a former pianist.
It is presented solely in black and white, much like the keys of piano. The lack of colour could stand as a metaphor for that he is missing something integral to his life - his limbs and with it the ability to play the piano.
At one point the character is sitting in front of the piano and begins to hit the keys with his chin, the frustration that it doesn't sound right is shown upon his face, as his frustration becomes more intense so does the force at which he is hitting the keys which therefore make a much harder and more abrupt diagetic sound that reflects his emotions through sound. The same happens when he tries to play with his feet but this time his movements and frustration become even more erratic and as a result he falls to the floor. As he hits the floor the screen fades to black before the next shot is shown which implies that an amount of time has passed. The character then struggles to get up from the floor and back into the chair. When he has done so he imagines himself playing the piano again and what it would sound like, this is shown through the uses of animation with his arms and hands being drawn over the top of the live action scene so as to look like they are his. A musical piece of what it would sound like is then played. The animation and subsequent sound is effective as it enables the viewer to understand why the character holds so much frustration as they can now hear how he
used to be able to play a piece music.
At first the camera movement is still but as the character's frustration builds so does the movement of the camera, it becomes somewhat more erratic to reflect his mood. When he falls the camera also gets to the same level on the floor and only goes back to its normal height when the character does so. The movements and angles finally become still and straight again when the character imagines himself playing the piano, this reflects the 'perfect moment' that the character is envisioning.
When the film ends and the final credits are shown the screen fades and all that can be seen is the keys of the piano and partially the character's face. This symbolises how important and central the piano is both to the narrative and to the character.
See You Soon
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKZQzaahN3c
The theme this film encounters is death and vanity.
There is no introduction, from the very first shot we are thrust right into the action. The protagonist has been stabbed for reasons we do not know, this immediately grabs the viewers attention and entices them as they have no grasp as to the type of character the protagonist is or how he came to be in this situation, they just want to know 'why?'. Again, we are not explicitly shown the action of the stabbing we are shown a shot of the knife in somebody's hand and blood making a stain on the protagonist's shirt, from these two simple images we can semetically construct that he has been stabbed. After this short scene we are shown a black title card with the film's title. In the next scene we see the character walking along the street clutching his chest, as we see the street ahead from his point of view he is beginning to see things out of focus, this implies that he is weakening from his blood loss. The character reaches his home and instead of calling for help like one might expect, he goes to the bathroom and searches for something he cannot find he therefore goes to the supermarket. As he walks back home his vision is worsening and he is weakening, this is shown through him clutching his chest in pain, limping home and crawling through the front door. He again goes into the bathroom and it is shown what has been bought - shaving cream. The character begins shaving his face but with great difficulty as he is weakening. In the next and final scene he is putting on a suit when he has done so we see a close up of his face as he grins, now we realise he has been preparing and dressing himself for death.
This film is also presented solely in black & white. The light and dark tones reflect life and death. The protagonist is wearing white whilst his attacker is dressed in black so to symbolise him as the 'bringer of death'. Each time he enters his home there is a bright white surrounding him, as a bright white light is conventionally believed in this context to symbolise death and progression into heaven we can assume that he is getting closer to death, each time this is stronger. As the character 'dresses for death' the predominant colour of his attire is black which symbolises death, as he falls to the floor a bright white envelopes around him until the screen is completely white. The credits then begin to roll. Taking 'pointers' from how colour has been used throughout the film, we can assume he has died.
Events and happenings within the narrative are completely silent and the only sound heard throughout the film is incidental music in the form of an instrumental piece which remains almost the same until the final moments when it becomes louder and longer.
The film as a whole is unsettling - A man close to death would rather 'dress for the occasion' than to seek medical help and his close up satisfied grin to the camera when he has accomplished this is far more disturbing than the knife attack itself could ever be.